Hi JV,
Sorry, Kevin, but I don't agree. First, an automatic transmission DOES
have a 2nd gear (and most cars will allow you to manually shift into it),
Aside from being irrelevant, an automatic transmission's 2nd gear is not the
same as a manual transmissions second gear. But again, it's the point that
is relevant, regardless of the quality of the analogy.
and second, I agree with the other post which recommends web user controls
for what they are trying to accomplish.
So, how does your agreeing with those recommendations disagree with mine? Of
course you're going to use Controls (Server Controls or User Controls). If I
don't mention that it's a nice day outside, am I contending with those who
do say so? Am I somehow saying that it's a nasty day outside?
Unless I misread the first post, they just want to re-use some of their
web code.
If you read the first shallowly, yes, that is exactly what he's asking.
However, the message also conveys the fact that he's not thinking OOP, which
means that, especially since he's part of a team, they need to change the
way they think about programming their ASP.Net apps, which means they need
to re-think their whole methodology.
Assuming that he took your advice, and used User Controls, how much more
would he know about ASP.Net by doing so? He would know that one thing. He
wouldn't even know that he could write his own Server Controls, and use
them, for example. If he studies the methodolody of OOP, he will know much
more, and not need as much help next time.
Hey, if you just want to feed him a fish, I'm not knocking you for it. I
prefer to teach a man to fish.
--
HTH,
Kevin Spencer
Microsoft MVP
..Net Developer
What You Seek Is What You Get.