Dataset and WS-I BP 1.1

[Rasheed]

The requirement is to build interoperable web services which should conform
to WS-I Basic Profile 1.1 (This requirement came little late in the
development life cycle). Some of the existing web services utilize Dataset as
return type and input parameters.

The web services by default contain the Following attribute (VS 2005, WSE
3.0):

[WebServiceBinding(ConformsTo =
WsiProfiles.BasicProfile1_1,EmitConformanceClaims=true)]

When we browse the web service it does not show any warnings about the usage
of Dataset. However, the following link says usage of Dataset would violate
BP rules.

http://msdn2.microsoft.com/en-us/library/ms230196.aspx

We really do not know the web service with Dataset conforms to BP 1.1 or
not. Since VS 2005 does not show any warnings, are we conforming to BP 1.1?

Your inputs will be really helpful

Thanks,
Rasheed

 

[Vijay Pandey]

Datasets, xmldocuments or any weakly typed data type does not conform to BP 1.1

 

[John Saunders]

Datasets, xmldocuments or any weakly typed data type does not conform to
BP 1.1

What about a strongly-typed dataset, or an XML document conforming to a
specified schema?

John

The requirement is to build interoperable web services which should
conform
to WS-I Basic Profile 1.1 (This requirement came little late in the
development life cycle). Some of the existing web services utilize
Dataset as
return type and input parameters.

The web services by default contain the Following attribute (VS 2005, WSE
3.0):

[WebServiceBinding(ConformsTo =
WsiProfiles.BasicProfile1_1,EmitConformanceClaims=true)]

When we browse the web service it does not show any warnings about the
usage
of Dataset. However, the following link says usage of Dataset would
violate
BP rules.

http://msdn2.microsoft.com/en-us/library/ms230196.aspx

We really do not know the web service with Dataset conforms to BP 1.1 or
not. Since VS 2005 does not show any warnings, are we conforming to BP
1.1?

Your inputs will be really helpful

Thanks,
Rasheed

 

[Rasheed]

Thanks Vijay. What is confusing is we do not get any warning when such data
types are used eventhough the WebServiceBinding is set as stated in my
previous post. And also, as John indicated, how about typed dataset?

Thanks for helping!
Rasheed

Datasets, xmldocuments or any weakly typed data type does not conform to BP 1.1

The requirement is to build interoperable web services which should conform
to WS-I Basic Profile 1.1 (This requirement came little late in the
development life cycle). Some of the existing web services utilize Dataset as
return type and input parameters.

The web services by default contain the Following attribute (VS 2005, WSE
3.0):

[WebServiceBinding(ConformsTo =
WsiProfiles.BasicProfile1_1,EmitConformanceClaims=true)]

When we browse the web service it does not show any warnings about the usage
of Dataset. However, the following link says usage of Dataset would violate
BP rules.

http://msdn2.microsoft.com/en-us/library/ms230196.aspx

We really do not know the web service with Dataset conforms to BP 1.1 or
not. Since VS 2005 does not show any warnings, are we conforming to BP 1.1?

Your inputs will be really helpful

Thanks,
Rasheed