alex said:
He is writing his application in C,
That does not automatically make this issue topical.
It's the *language* itself which is the topic, not
any possible application of it.
Also, note that in comp.lang.c the term "C language" means
ISO standard C. Any included code falling outside that domain
causes the program to cease being a C program. This issue is
outside that domain.
You knew it was not topical, but you:
1) Did not indicate this to the OP.
2) Posted an equally off-topic message.
Instead of being nasty (like you),
As I'm pointing out in this message, it was *your* behavior
that was 'nasty' (perhaps 'disrespectful' would describe it
better), not Joona's. Joona has been a very helpful,
polite poster here for a very long time. He has already
proven his expertise to us. Regardless of who might have
written it, I cannot see how the question: "And what do you
think any of this has to do with C?" could be considered 'nasty'.
"Terse", perhaps, but imo emotionally neutral.
Actually your reply was potentially far more harmful than
helpful.
because I knew
the answer to his question.
I know the answers to many questions which are not topical
(but many of which are asked) here. But they're not topical,
so I don't answer them here (if I answer at all, it would be
with a notification about topicality, and possibly a redirection
to a more appropriate group.
Just relax ok? It hasnt hurt anyone/anything.
You have potentially harmed a large number of individuals,
because your off-topic answer could lead them to believe
that this is indeed a C issue when it's really not. This
misinformation can and does harm them and others; in
both learning and commercial enviroments, in many ways.
These are issues which cause the 'regulars' to point out
off-topic material. I certainly don't want to end up
working with someone who does not really know C but
believes he does.
Finally, please see the "welcome message" to which I posted
a link elsewhere in this thread. Thank you.
-Mike